Physiotherapy for Whiplash

How Physical Therapy Can Help After a Whiplash Injury

Physical therapy can help reduce pain, restore neck movement, and enable you to resume your activities after whiplash. It combines tailored advice and exercises; manual techniques may complement the treatment. The progress and duration of recovery vary depending on the injury and the individual.¹ If you’d like to learn more about cervical sprain and whiplash, check out our comprehensive guide to cervical sprain.

After a car accident, neck pain, stiffness, headaches, or dizziness can be very concerning. A thorough evaluation is recommended if symptoms are severe or worsening. Seek immediate medical attention if you experience severe weakness, significant loss of sensation, or a recent loss of balance while walking. If you experience double vision or dizziness, see your physical therapist right away.

Research provides some useful guidelines, while still leaving significant room for individual assessment:

• An active approach helps patients resume their activities: advice and gradual movements are part of the recommendations following a whiplash injury without complications.² A 2008 international review reports favorable results for informational videos, mobilizations, and exercises compared to standard care or certain physical therapies. Mobilizations are neck movements performed by the patient or guided by a healthcare professional.³
• Results vary depending on the treatment and the individual: conservative treatments are non-surgical approaches, such as advice, exercises, and manual techniques.⁴ A 2007 Cochrane review identified 23 very different studies, several of which were of low quality. It was not possible to confidently recommend a specific treatment for all Grade I and II whiplash injuries.⁴ This uncertainty does not mean that all of these treatments are ineffective.

Our guide to whiplash explains when symptoms appear and what can help assess the risk of complications.

The care plan links your symptoms and exam results to the activities you want to resume. To learn about other causes of cervical pain—that is, neck pain—see our comprehensive guide.

The goal is to help you understand your situation, track your progress, and gradually resume the activities that are important to you.

Understanding Whiplash, Also Known as Neck Injury

Whiplash is a sudden movement in which the head and neck are first accelerated and then decelerated. During a rear-end collision, the head may be thrown backward and then forward.⁵ This mechanism can occur in other types of trauma and cause a neck injury, but it does not, on its own, refer to a specific injury.⁶

The mechanism of whiplash and the Quebec Task Force's severity grades are described in our guide on cervical sprain.

What symptoms can accompany whiplash?

Whiplash may be accompanied by neck pain and stiffness, headaches, shoulder tension, dizziness or lightheadedness, and fatigue. Dizziness causes a sensation of spinning; lightheadedness can cause a feeling of unsteadiness. Symptoms vary from person to person.

In a trial involving 71 people with persistent neck pain following an accident, two treatment programs were compared over a 10-week period. Participants were randomly assigned to one of the two programs. Both groups showed improvement, but physical therapy that combined multiple approaches reduced pain and functional limitations more effectively than self-management advice and exercises.⁷ The sensitivity studied included, in particular, increased pain in response to pressure or cold. A supplementary analysis suggested a smaller improvement with both programs among certain highly sensitive individuals; however, this finding alone is not sufficient to guide treatment selection.

Our guide on neck sprains also describes the symptoms that can follow a whiplash injury.

• Severe weakness or paralysis of a hand, arm, or leg
• Recurring loss of balance, difficulty walking or sitting upright
• New-onset loss of bladder or bowel control
• Very severe pain that increases rapidly or is accompanied by significant discomfort
• A sudden sensation of an electric shock in the neck or back, which may also extend to the arms or legs
• Severe pain despite taking the recommended pain medication

Tingling, numbness, double vision, or dizziness do not require a trip to the emergency room. In these cases, see your physical therapist as soon as possible.

What role can physical therapy play after a whiplash injury?

Physical therapy helps restore neck movement and resume activities limited by pain through tailored advice and exercises. The physical therapist first looks for any concerning signs and assesses your abilities. The Australian SIRA guidelines, intended for professionals who treat injuries following an accident, recommend an active approach for whiplash cases without fractures or dislocations.¹ An international review also supports care focused on resuming activities, without identifying a single treatment as superior in all situations.³

The MINT trial, published in 2013, compared two stages of care. In the emergency department, an active counseling program showed no advantage over standard counseling at 12 months. Among 599 people whose symptoms persisted thereafter, up to six physical therapy sessions reduced functional limitations slightly more at four months than a single counseling session. This benefit was no longer clearly observed at eight or twelve months.⁸ These results compare specific treatments; they do not mean that all physical therapy is ineffective.

Physiotherapy treatment for whiplash-associated disorder is divided into three parts:

• Assessment of factors that may contribute to symptoms and treatment tailored to the results
• Planning Your Return to Work or School (Cognitive Activities)
• Planning your return to sports and other leisure activities

Care that promotes movement and activities

A 2015 Cochrane review evaluated exercises for various types of neck pain, with or without headaches or nerve root involvement. A nerve root is the part of a nerve near the spine. For persistent pain, certain strength and endurance programs targeting the neck, shoulders, and arms improved pain and functional ability. The certainty of these results was moderate for several comparisons. No trials focused exclusively on very recent pain; this lack of studies does not prove a lack of benefit.⁹

A 1986 study of 61 people who had experienced whiplash compared early movement with rest while wearing a soft neck brace. At eight weeks, the participants who began moving early had greater range of motion and less pain.¹⁰ The results apply to these two programs and these participants.

Based on the results of the assessment, the active approach may include:

• Manual therapy as a short-term relief option to facilitate movement, if the evaluation and your preferences indicate that it is appropriate
• Therapeutic exercises selected based on the patient's ability to work, the targeted activities, and the response to the exercises
• Information and advice to help you understand symptoms, monitor their progression, and participate in decision-making
• Gradual resumption of activities based on observed capabilities and the demands of daily life

Non-surgical treatments that support movement and daily activities are generally preferred over prolonged immobilization without a medical indication.³ However, the results of comparisons vary. A trial involving 458 participants compared a rigid neck brace followed by movement, advice to continue activities, and an active movement program. At one year, the analyses showed no clear difference between these strategies in terms of pain, functional limitations, or work capacity.¹¹ This does not prove that all three options yield the same outcome for every person.

Understanding the Risk of Persistent Symptoms

In some people, pain or functional limitations persist after the injury. This possibility warrants appropriate follow-up, although it does not allow for predicting individual outcomes.

The following factors may be associated with a more difficult recovery or may require special attention:

• Significant disability from the outset¹² : The term “disability” here refers to difficulty with everyday activities, not a medical diagnosis. A meta-review published in 2017, which revisits previously published reviews, links the difficulty experienced in the early days to its persistence
• Severe initial pain¹³ : A 2009 review with a meta-analysis lists severe neck pain at the onset as one of the factors associated with persistent difficulties. The term “onset” here refers to the very first few days after the collision
• Severe weakness or significant loss of sensation: seek medical attention immediately
• Prolonged immobilization when not medically necessary
• Fear of movement that severely limits activities¹⁴ : In clinical settings, a yellow flag indicates a psychological or social factor that may complicate the resumption of activities. A study published in 2009 involving 147 people links fear of movement to greater discomfort and more depressive symptoms

The plan can be adjusted based on the test results, the targeted activities, and the observed response. The next appointment will help determine whether these adjustments are helping you.

How does a physical therapy evaluation work?

A physical therapy evaluation includes a discussion about the injury and symptoms, followed by an assessment of movement, strength, and sensation. The physical therapist also checks for signs that require medical attention and identifies activities that are difficult for you to perform.The initial physical therapy evaluation is used to determine possible causes and develop a plan with you. No single test can definitively identify the tissue responsible for all of your symptoms.

Understanding Trauma and Its Course

The physical therapist will ask you questions about, among other things:

• The mechanism of injury—including the type of impact and seat belt use—as contextual factors rather than definitive predictors of recovery
• When each symptom first appeared and the changes observed since then
• Symptoms that improve, remain stable, or worsen
• Daily activities—whether work-related or sports-related—that have become difficult
• Medical history that may affect the examination or the precautions to be taken

The Neck Disability Index (NDI) is a ten-item questionnaire about neck pain and its effects, including on daily activities, sleep, and concentration. The score helps compare reported difficulties from one visit to the next. The 1991 study examined the stability of repeated responses and their agreement with other measures.¹⁵ The questionnaire complements the interview and physical examination; it does not, on its own, measure recovery or identify the affected tissue.

Assess capabilities and look for warning signs

The examination may include the following, depending on the symptoms:

Measuring neck movement: The physical therapist measures how far you can turn your head, look down or up, and tilt your head to the side. These measurements alone do not confirm the severity of the injury.

Strength and endurance tests: The physical therapist assesses the amount of force the neck and shoulder muscles can generate and sustain. These capabilities guide the selection and progression of exercises.

Examination of tender areas: The physical therapist applies pressure with their fingers to examine the muscles of the neck and shoulders. The reproduction of pain is interpreted in conjunction with other findings; it is not sufficient on its own to determine which tissue is causing the pain.

Nerve examination: The physical therapist checks reflexes, sensation, and strength in the arms to identify possible nerve damage and determine whether a medical evaluation is necessary.

Additional tests: Depending on the symptoms, the physical therapist also assesses joint stability and the precision of head movements. Several test results must be considered together before attributing the symptoms to a joint, disc, or ligament.

Your physical therapist can evaluate your neck, balance, and eye movements based on your symptoms:

• The vestibular system (responsible for balance)
• The oculomotor system (responsible for eye coordination)
• The cervical spine (the neck vertebrae)

To assess your neck, your physiotherapist will evaluate the following:

• Your joint mobility
• The gliding of your nerves
• Your postural habits
• The quality of your movements
• Your strength and stability

Exam Results and Possible Outcomes

After the interview and the exam, the results are used to determine the next steps:

• The physical therapist classifies the symptoms and findings according to the whiplash classification system, when appropriate.
• The physical therapist explains the factors involved in the progression of your condition, without predicting your outcome with certainty.
• The plan links the results of the review to your priorities.
• The frequency of our meetings is determined in consultation with you and adjusted as needed based on your progress.
• The goals describe the important activities you want to resume.

What types of interventions can be included in the plan?

The physical therapy plan may combine exercises, advice, manual techniques, and methods for temporary relief. The choice depends on your symptoms, the results of your examination, your goals, and your response to treatment. The program evolves based on your abilities, rather than following a one-size-fits-all approach.

Based on the assessment results, your physiotherapist will:

• Mobilize the joints, muscles, and nerves in your neck to reduce pain and improve movement
• Will provide you with tailored exercises to improve your range of motion, strength, and endurance for daily activities
• Will help you balance your daily activities and leisure time based on your response
• Will give you advice on your posture and movement habits

Manual therapy, if it supports an active goal

Manual therapy involves movements or pressure applied with the hands. It can complement exercises to provide short-term relief or improve range of motion. Results vary depending on the technique and the individual.¹ A 2010 review on persistent whiplash found stronger evidence supporting short-term exercise programs than joint manipulation. Joint manipulation—a brief, rapid movement of a joint—was based at that time on a series of case studies without a comparison group.¹⁶ This limitation applies to this specific technique and this review; it does not refute all manual therapy.

Guided neck movements: The physical therapist may gently move the joints between the vertebrae in your neck to facilitate movement or provide temporary relief. The force and range of motion are adjusted based on your response.¹ The studies included in a 2007 Cochrane review varied too widely to confidently recommend a single method for everyone.⁴

Another trial, involving 101 people with recent whiplash, compared a tailored program involving multiple professionals to standard care. It did not show a clear benefit in terms of recovery at six or twelve months.¹⁷ The number and type of treatments should be determined based on the assessment.

Manual muscle therapy: Applying pressure or performing movements on the neck and shoulder muscles may provide temporary relief. This response does not prove that a specific muscle is causing the pain and is not a substitute for exercise and a return to normal activities.

Myofascial release refers to an approach that applies pressure or stretching to the tissues surrounding the muscles. Physioactif does not include this approach in its whiplash treatment plan.

Decision Before Neck Treatment: The physical therapist explains your options after the evaluation and asks for your consent. You can ask questions, choose a different option, or refuse a procedure.

Short-Term Relief Measures

Heat or cold: Applying heat or cold to the neck may provide temporary relief for some people. A 2004 review describes their use for muscle and joint pain in general, with possible effects on pain and cramps; it does not establish a specific outcome for all cases of whiplash.¹⁸ Protect the skin and stop use if an unusual reaction occurs. Heat and cold can cause burns or skin damage. They are not a substitute for appropriate exercises and are not intended to repair or stretch tissues.

Adhesive strips on the skin: Therapeutic taping involves applying strips to a specific area of the body. A 2015 review found a small, very short-term reduction in pain with elastic strips in some studies on whiplash or neck pain. The quality of the evidence was low; the authors could not draw firm conclusions about their clinical usefulness.¹⁹ The use of tape may be considered for comfort, and its effects should be reevaluated. This review did not establish any tissue-repairing effects.

Information, Expectations, and Shared Decisions

Understanding the test results and the role of the various options helps you make informed decisions about next steps.

In a trial published in 2005, 405 people received either an informational video following a rear-end collision or standard care. At 24 weeks, the median reduction in pain was greater with the video: three points versus two. The proportion of people still experiencing symptoms was also 7.9 percentage points lower, but this difference remained uncertain upon further analysis.²⁰ The video may therefore help improve certain outcomes without guaranteeing that symptoms will disappear.

The explanations may cover, among other things:

• What the examination helps monitor: understanding why pain does not always indicate a serious injury—without implying that the clinical examination rules out all possible causes
• Gradual resumption of movement: choosing manageable movements and adjusting them based on their effect during and after the activity
• Variability in Recovery: Focus on Personal Milestones Rather Than a Schedule Presented as Set in Stone
• Ways to manage symptoms on a daily basis: adjust your sleep, work, and activities according to your symptoms and limitations, without trying to find the “perfect” position
• Common Misconceptions That Need to Be Clarified: Reasons to Avoid Complete Rest or Prolonged Use of a Neck Brace When There Is No Medical Indication for Them

These explanations can help the person participate in decision-making, interpret their symptoms, and adjust their activities. Their effect on anxiety, program completion, or recovery varies from person to person.

What exercises can be recommended after a whiplash injury?

Exercises after a whiplash injury may include slow neck movements, gentle contractions against a hand, and shoulder control exercises. The physical therapist will select the exercises based on your abilities, daily activities, and response to treatment.

A trial involving 216 people with persistent grade II or III symptoms compared neck exercises—with or without support for managing pain-related behaviors—to a general physical activity prescription. Both neck exercise programs reduced functional limitations more effectively and facilitated daily activities at one year. At two years, each program maintained an advantage on one of these two measures, with no clear difference between the two neck exercise programs.

Among those who continued at least some of their exercises, 61% of the neck exercise group without behavioral intervention reported a reduction in pain of at least half after one year, compared with 26% in the general physical activity group. This difference was no longer clear at two years. Pain scores did not differ significantly between the groups. The results are encouraging, but 43% of participants did not complete the two-year follow-up, which limits the certainty of the findings.²¹

The PROMISE trial compared twenty exercise sessions to a counseling session with a physical therapist and telephone support among 172 people who had had Grade I or II whiplash for more than three months but less than five years. The twenty sessions did not result in any further reduction in pain at fourteen weeks, six months, or one year.²² The comparison group also received active care. A 2007 trial showed small benefits from adding exercises to counseling on pain and activities at six weeks, but no clear difference between the groups at twelve months.²³ This does not mean that each person’s progress had disappeared.

The following examples show exercises to choose with your physical therapist after an evaluation. They are not automatically suitable for every injury. Perform the movements slowly, without straining to the point of pain. The number of repetitions and the resistance are tailored to your situation. Exercises from the SIRA guide, Appendix 3¹, include neck movements, gentle contractions, and shoulder control exercises.

Stop exercising and seek medical advice or consult your physical therapist if you experience dizziness, a feeling of unease, blurred vision, fainting, or disorientation. Do the same if you experience sudden pain in your arm, if neck pain becomes unusually severe, or if the exercise regularly causes persistent headaches. Severe weakness, significant loss of sensation, or a recent loss of balance while walking require immediate medical attention. New numbness or double vision require you to consult your physical therapist promptly.

To begin with: getting back to a manageable level of activity

Before you begin, sit down or stand in a stable position. Perform each movement slowly and within a comfortable range of motion. Seek immediate medical attention if you experience severe weakness, significant loss of sensation, or a recent loss of balance while walking. If you experience new numbness or double vision, see your physical therapist right away.

• Position: sitting or standing, looking straight ahead
• Slowly turn your head to the right as far as you can comfortably go, without straining
• Return to the center in a controlled manner
• Then turn to the left within the same range of motion; stop if the pain becomes sharp

• While sitting or standing, slowly bring your chin toward your chest as far as you can comfortably go, without straining
• Slowly return to the starting position, without straining
• Starting from the center, slowly look upward until you reach a comfortable limit; stop if the pain becomes sharp

• Whether sitting or standing, slowly tilt your head toward your right shoulder without raising your shoulder, as far as is comfortable
• Slowly return to the center, without holding the position or trying to stretch
• Return to the center, then tilt your head toward your left shoulder within the same comfortable range; stop if the pain becomes sharp

Signs to watch for: Stop moving. Seek immediate medical attention if you experience severe weakness, significant loss of sensation, or a recent loss of balance while walking. If you experience new numbness, double vision, or severe dizziness, see your physical therapist right away.

When exercise is better tolerated: strength and endurance

The following exercises focus on strength, endurance, or control related to the activities. The resistance and range of motion are adjusted to maintain a comfortable level of effort.

A slight nod of the head while lying down: this movement is described in the South Tees physical therapy fact sheet²⁴.

• Lie on your back with your head comfortably supported and your eyes looking up at the ceiling
• Make a slight “yes” motion by bringing your chin slightly toward your throat. Keep your head resting on the support—do not push against it or lift it up.
• Gently return to the starting position while breathing normally. The movement should remain easy and pain-free.

Position sense allows the head to return to its starting position without relying solely on visual cues. A 2007 trial involving 64 women with persistent neck pain and difficulties with precision compared two programs over a six-week period. Both programs improved precision, pain levels, and functional activities. The program focused on position sense performed better only in returning to the center after a rotation to the right.²⁵ This result does not indicate that one exercise is superior for everyone.

• Sit down and place your right hand against your right cheek
• Gently try to turn your head to the right while your hand resists the movement. Keep the pressure light.
• Stop as soon as your condition worsens or your symptoms increase significantly
• Next, place your hand on the left side only if no new neurological symptoms have appeared; otherwise, consult your physical therapist promptly, or immediately if you experience severe weakness.

Checking the shoulder blades: The shoulder blades are the flat bones located behind the shoulders.

• Position: standing or sitting, with arms relaxed at your sides
• Whether sitting or standing, gently bring your shoulder blades together without shrugging your shoulders or holding your breath
• Stop before the quality of the movement deteriorates; stop if the pain becomes sharp, and consult your physical therapist promptly if you notice any new neurological symptoms, or immediately if you experience severe weakness.

Bringing your shoulder blades together is a way to exercise shoulder control. The physical therapist will assess whether this exercise is helpful for your activities.

Later: endurance, coordination, and a return to activities

Progressing through the exercises involves increasing or adjusting the level of difficulty, such as the range of motion, resistance, or duration. The physical therapist will take your response into account before modifying the program. Seek medical attention immediately if you experience severe weakness, significant loss of sensation, or a recent loss of balance while walking. If you experience new numbness or double vision, see your physical therapist right away.

Elastic Band Pull: This exercise targets the muscles behind the shoulders. It is from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons’ shoulder conditioning program²⁶; your physical therapist will determine whether it is appropriate for you following your neck injury.

• Attach an elastic band to a stable point and hold it upright, with your elbow bent close to your body.
• Keep your arm close to your body and gently pull your elbow backward.
• Bring your shoulder blades together, then slowly return to the starting position.
• Choose a resistance level that is easy to control and pain-free; ask for an adjustment if the exercise causes symptoms.

• Position sense exercises: moving the head toward a target after a movement, using a visual cue to check accuracy.
• One way to coordinate your eyes and head is to look at a target to the side while keeping your head still at first, then gently turning your head toward the target. The North Bristol Physical Therapy Department²⁷ describes this movement. It should be selected and taught following an examination, taking care not to trigger new symptoms.

A balance exercise should only be considered if the evaluation reveals a relevant difficulty. Start on a stable surface with a support within reach. Consult your physical therapist immediately if you experience new dizziness or double vision.

• If your physical therapist thinks it’s appropriate, place one foot in front of the other while keeping one hand on a sturdy countertop and looking straight ahead. Then return to a comfortable position. This example is included in the Worcestershire balance exercises²⁸. The support and duration are adjusted accordingly; do not continue if you feel unsteady.

• Before getting back behind the wheel, discuss the requirements for turning, monitoring, and concentration. Do not drive if double vision, new weakness, loss of sensation, or dizziness compromise safety; consult your physical therapist promptly, or immediately in the event of severe weakness.
• For work tasks, discuss possible temporary accommodations based on the required actions and the observed abilities
• When returning to sports and recreational activities, discuss the skills you need to re-learn and the abilities required before deciding on the next steps

Thetherapeutic exercise program is tailored to the abilities you need to regain, your preferences, and your response to the program.

How can I monitor my recovery from whiplash?

Follow-up after whiplash involves comparing pain, neck movement, sleep, and functional ability from one visit to the next. Fluctuations are common. In a 2008 meta-analysis, the average improvement was most pronounced during the first three months and then slowed.²⁹ These averages do not set a limit on your recovery. A longer recovery period does not, in and of itself, indicate a new injury or a failure of treatment.²⁹

Choose objectives and follow-up measures based on the situation

• Possible goal: to understand the symptoms, maintain a level of movement that is tolerable, or resume basic activities
• Frequency: determined in consultation with the individual based on their need for support, safety, and independence

• Possible goal: to adapt movement, strength, or endurance to a chosen activity
• Frequency: revised based on observed changes and the expected value of the next meeting

• Possible goal: to perform a specific task related to work, leisure, or sports
• Frequency: reduced, maintained, or discontinued depending on the individual's autonomy, needs, and agreed-upon goals

The goals, exercises, and frequency of sessions are adjusted based on the changes observed and the individual’s priorities, with no set sequence or expected percentage to be achieved by a specific date.

Decide how often to meet

The frequency of meetings is determined on an individual basis. It may vary depending on the need for guidance, any changes observed, the goals, and the ability to follow the plan independently.

Items to Document During Follow-Up

• Pain and disability measured at baseline and compared at follow-up
• Associated symptoms noted at the start and compared with those at follow-up
• Psychological distress reported at baseline and compared at follow-up
• Observed ability to resume certain activities without a lasting increase in symptoms
• Results of the neurological examination and any changes observed during follow-up

• High initial pain
• Severe headaches at the start of follow-up
• New numbness or weakness: see your physical therapist as soon as possible, or immediately if the weakness is severe
• Longer period of immobilization; this should be interpreted in light of the medical reason
• Severe anxiety or fear of movement that limits activities
• Administrative, professional, or insurance-related circumstances that add to stress or complicate a return to normal activities

A review published in 2016 describes three possible outcomes: rapid improvement, partial improvement, or persistent difficulties. It introduces WhipPredict, a tool that estimates the risk of activity limitations following a whiplash injury.³⁰ At that time, three prediction models had been validated by other research groups, but their impact on clinical decisions and treatment outcomes had not yet been tested. These tools complement the assessment; they do not provide an individual prognosis.

Guidelines for Tracking Your Progress

• A decrease in the intensity or impact of pain over time
• Sufficient neck movement to perform more useful tasks
• Exercises that are of higher quality or easier to manage
• Sleep less disrupted by symptoms
• Increased participation in daily activities, even though some symptoms remain
• Headaches that occur less frequently or are less bothersome

If activities remain difficult or if symptoms worsen, the physical therapist reassesses the possible causes, the goals, and the need for a second medical opinion.

How should follow-up care be adjusted when symptoms persist?

The physical therapist tailors exercises, activities, sleep strategies, and the necessary support when symptoms persist. The physical therapist may coordinate care with a doctor or another professional. Managing chronic pain—which lasts more than three months—also takes into account stress, work, and your priorities.

Our guide to whiplash explains why neck pain can last for several months.

Take early action without promising a specific outcome

In Rosenfeld’s trial, 97 participants were assigned to one of two programs, which began either within 96 hours or after two weeks. The active program reduced pain more significantly at six months than the standard program. Among participants in the active program, earlier initiation led to better outcomes in terms of pain and neck flexion.³¹ The Kongsted trial, involving 458 participants recruited within ten days, showed no clear difference at one year between a cervical collar followed by exercises, activity guidance, and active exercises.¹¹ Active care may help, but these comparisons do not guarantee that an early intervention program will prevent any persistent pain.

Early assessment: The physical therapist looks for signs that require medical evaluation, measures baseline abilities, and describes possible activities. This information is used to determine the appropriate initial treatment.

Getting Back on Track When Fear Limits Your Activities

The fear of moving is understandable after an accident. The fear-avoidance model suggests that a fear of pain can lead to avoiding activities and contribute to functional limitations. A 2009 study of 147 people found a link between the fear of moving, worrying thoughts, functional limitations, and depressive symptoms.¹⁴ The measurements were taken at the same time: they do not prove that fear causes pain or that it is the only explanation.

• Together with your physical therapist, you can choose an activity you’ve been avoiding to clarify what’s concerning you and what you’d like to resume doing
• The starting level can be adjusted depending on the situation, for example, by reducing the distance of the movement, the effort, or the duration
• Symptoms and possible activities after the trial can be noted to inform the next decision
• The response reported during and after the trial can be used to decide, together with the physical therapist, whether the next trial should be continued, scaled back, or modified.

Seek medical attention immediately if you experience severe weakness, significant loss of sensation, or a recent loss of balance while walking. If you experience new numbness or double vision, see your physical therapist right away. If you experience a marked and persistent increase in symptoms without these signs, stop the activity and discuss an adjustment with your physical therapist.

Minimize downtime when it is not necessary

In this trial, 458 participants seen within ten days of sustaining a whiplash injury were divided into three groups. The first group received immobilization with a rigid neck brace followed by mobilization. The second group was advised to continue their usual activities. The third group received active mobilization. At one year, no significant differences were observed among the three groups in terms of pain, disability, or work capacity¹¹. A result described as statistically significant meets the threshold chosen for the analysis. This does not rule out chance and does not guarantee a meaningful effect in daily life. The absence of a clear difference does not prove that the three approaches are equally effective for every individual.

Before changing a prescription: If a collar has been prescribed, do not change how it is worn without verifying the reason for the prescription and the instructions from the treating professional.

Factors observed during follow-up

The factors observed in individuals who were monitored following a collision are presented in our guide on whiplash.

• Thoughts about recovery: the person’s thoughts about their recovery and the activities they fear
• Avoided activities: movements, tasks, or situations that are limited due to a fear of worsening the condition
• Reported emotional state: anxiety, mood, or post-traumatic symptoms described during the interview
• Personal context: reported impacts on work, loved ones, daily routines, and important activities

The physical therapist can discuss these factors with you without placing blame and adjust the treatment plan accordingly. Significant or persistent distress may also warrant help from another professional. Support may include the following:

• Reassuring explanations based on the test results, without promising a quick recovery
• The selected exercise can be repeated at the level agreed upon with the physical therapist and then adjusted based on your response
• Recognizing emotions and choosing realistic activities to resume
• Discussion of a consultation with a psychologist or other professional when distress or post-traumatic stress goes beyond the scope of physical therapy

Discuss accommodations for important activities

A 2001 review on the prognosis of whiplash highlighted the link between initial pain or functional limitations and persistent difficulties.³² Regarding a return to work, the SIRA guidelines recommend staying active while adapting tasks as needed.¹ Specific adjustments are chosen based on the nature of the job and your abilities.

• A reduced schedule or a partial return to work may be discussed if the usual work hours remain difficult to manage.
• Adjusting the workstation—such as moving equipment closer or varying tasks—can make certain movements easier.
• A discussion with the employer can clarify what tasks are feasible, any temporary limitations, and what adjustments need to be reviewed.
• You can increase the difficulty one task at a time, based on your abilities and the actual requirements.

The physical therapist can document the observed abilities and limitations. Work accommodations remain options to be discussed based on each person’s tasks, work environment, and responsibilities.

How important is a cervical collar after a whiplash injury?

A cervical collar is not routinely recommended after a whiplash injury without a fracture or dislocation; the SIRA guidelines emphasize appropriate movements and a return to activities.¹ However, a neck brace may still be indicated for certain injuries, depending on the medical evaluation. If one has been prescribed for you, verify the reason for it and the instructions before changing how you use it.

A rigid collar designed to restrict movement and a soft collar used temporarily serve different purposes. Therefore, the reason for the prescription must be known before interpreting the results of a test.

Conclusions Based on the Available Studies

In the cited study, a neck brace, continued activity, and active mobilization were compared as three specific strategies. The results do not identify the medical rationale for prescribing a neck brace to a patient.

What the study shows: The study comparing the collar, continued activities, and active mobilization did not show any benefit of the collar after one year.¹¹ Published in 2007, the study included 458 participants recruited within ten days of their injury. The lack of benefit from the neck brace applies to the comparison made in this study, not to any specific medical indication. It does not demonstrate that wearing the brace for a specific duration is harmful for every individual.

Another study, involving 70 people with recent Grade II whiplash, compared two days of soft collar use with ten days. All participants received medication and began the same physical therapy program after seven days. The analyses showed no clear difference between the two collar-wearing durations in terms of pain, range of motion, or functional limitations at two or six months.³³ This comparison does not involve a neck brace prescribed for a fracture.

Issues to Clarify Before Changing How a Collar Is Used

In a 2000 trial involving 97 people, an active exercise program reduced pain more significantly at the six-month mark than the standard program. Among those following the active program, starting within 96 hours yielded better results in terms of pain and range of motion than starting after two weeks.³¹ These results do not justify removing a neck brace prescribed for a fracture or other serious injury.

• What medical indication justifies the collar, and what injuries were being assessed for?
• What instructions for wearing and removing the device did the prescribing professional provide?
• How can we resume our activities once it is safe to do so?
• When should the need for the collar be reassessed?

• Confirmed or suspected fracture, instability, or other serious injury
• Severe weakness or a significant loss of sensation requires immediate medical attention.
• Specific medical guidelines that have not yet been reevaluated
• Doubts about the reason for the prescription or the safety of discontinuation

Points to document rather than a predetermined protocol

When the evaluation leads to treatment without routine immobilization, record the baseline variables and compare them to the same variables at follow-up:

• Direction, distance, and number of repetitions of the movements attempted
• Temporary reaction to heat or cold, including any skin reaction
• Medications previously taken and instructions received from the pharmacist or prescriber
• Sleeping positions that the person finds comfortable

• Need for supervision during observed exercises
• Immediate and delayed responses to manual interventions, when tested
• Changes in possible movements and activities since the previous measurement
• Daily Activities Resumed and Tasks That Remain Challenging

A trial involving 47 people whose symptoms had persisted for several weeks compared supervised, tailored training with a home-based program. At three months, the supervised training led to greater confidence in one’s abilities and a greater reduction in fear of movement and activity limitations.³⁴ Supervised training also reduced the frequency of pain medication use to a greater extent. Some of these improvements were maintained at nine months. The analyses did not show any clear differences in pain, physical measures, or sick leave. These results support certain benefits of supervised training without promising an advantage in all aspects.

If you have ever been prescribed a neck brace

If you have been prescribed a neck brace, the following points may help you prepare for your discussion with your healthcare provider:

1. Question: What injury or risk still justifies wearing the neck brace?
2. Planned Change: What instructions have been given regarding changing or discontinuing the use of masks?
3. Movement: Which movements have been authorized, and which ones are still pending?
4. Symptoms to Report: What Changes Should Prompt a New Evaluation?

The trials compare specific strategies and follow-up protocols. They do not replace a medical recommendation for a neck brace or an assessment of movement and activity goals. Manual therapy remains a separate option from immobilization.

References

1. State Insurance Regulatory Authority. Guidelines for the Management of Acute Whiplash-Associated Disorders for Health Professionals. 3rd edition. 2014. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th references
2. French National Health Authority. Physical Therapy for Common Neck Pain and “Whiplash.” ↩ Back to text
3. Hurwitz EL, Carragee EJ, van der Velde G, Carroll LJ, Nordin M, Guzman J, et al. Treatment of neck pain: noninvasive interventions: results of the Bone and Joint Decade 2000–2010 Task Force on Neck Pain and Its Associated Disorders. Spine (Phila, Pa, 1976). 2008;33(4 Suppl):S123-52. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd, 3rd citations
4. Verhagen AP, Scholten-Peeters GG, van Wijngaarden S, de Bie RA, Bierma-Zeinstra SM. Conservative treatments for whiplash. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007;2007(2):CD003338. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd, 3rd citations
5. Alektoroff K, Papanagiotou P. [Whiplash injury of the cervical spine]. Radiologe. 2021;61(8):710-713. ↩ Back to text
6. Yadla S, Ratliff JK, Harrop JS. Whiplash: diagnosis, treatment, and associated injuries. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2008;1(1):65-8. ↩ Back to text
7. Jull G, Sterling M, Kenardy J, Beller E. Does the presence of sensory hypersensitivity influence outcomes of physical rehabilitation for chronic whiplash?—A preliminary RCT. Pain. 2007;129(1-2):28-34. ↩ Back to text
8. Lamb SE, Gates S, Williams MA, Williamson EM, Mt-Isa S, Withers EJ, et al. Emergency department treatments and physical therapy for acute whiplash: a pragmatic, two-step, randomized controlled trial. Lancet. 2013;381(9866):546-56. ↩ Back to text
9. Gross A, Kay TM, Paquin JP, Blanchette S, Lalonde P, Christie T, et al. Exercises for mechanical neck disorders. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015;1(1):CD004250. ↩ Back to text
10. Mealy K, Brennan H, Fenelon GC. Early mobilization of acute whiplash injuries. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1986;292(6521):656-7. ↩ Back to text
11. Kongsted A, Qerama E, Kasch H, Bendix T, Bach FW, Korsholm L, et al. Neck collar, "business as usual," or active mobilization for whiplash injury? A randomized parallel-group trial. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2007;32(6):618-26. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th citations
12. Sarrami P, Armstrong E, Naylor JM, Harris IA. Factors predicting outcome in whiplash injury: a systematic meta-review of prognostic factors. J Orthop Traumatol. 2017;18(1):9-16. ↩ Back to text
13. Walton DM, Pretty J, MacDermid JC, Teasell RW. Risk factors for persistent problems following whiplash injury: results of a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2009;39(5):334-50. ↩ Back to text
14. Nieto R, Miró J, Huguet A. The fear-avoidance model in whiplash injuries. Eur J Pain. 2009;13(5):518-23. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd citations
15. Vernon H, Mior S. The Neck Disability Index: A Study of Reliability and Validity. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1991;14(7):409-15. ↩ Back to text
16. Teasell RW, McClure JA, Walton D, Pretty J, Salter K, Meyer M, et al. A research synthesis of therapeutic interventions for whiplash-associated disorder (WAD): Part 4—Noninvasive interventions for chronic WAD. Pain Res Manag. 2010;15(5):313-22. ↩ Back to text
17. Jull G, Kenardy J, Hendrikz J, Cohen M, Sterling M. Management of acute whiplash: a randomized controlled trial of multidisciplinary stratified treatments. Pain. 2013;154(9):1798-1806. ↩ Back to text
18. Nadler SF, Weingand K, Kruse RJ. The Physiological Basis and Clinical Applications of Cryotherapy and Thermotherapy for the Pain Practitioner. Pain Physician. 2004;7(3):395-9. ↩ Back to text
19. Vanti C, Bertozzi L, Gardenghi I, Turoni F, Guccione AA, Pillastrini P. Effect of taping on spinal pain and disability: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials. Phys Ther. 2015;95(4):493-506. ↩ Back to text
20. Brison RJ, Hartling L, Dostaler S, Leger A, Rowe BH, Stiell I, et al. A randomized controlled trial of an educational intervention to prevent chronic pain associated with whiplash-related disorders following rear-end motor vehicle collisions. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2005;30(16):1799-807. ↩ Back to text
21. Ludvigsson ML, Peterson G, Dedering Å, Peolsson A. One- and two-year follow-up of a randomized trial of neck-specific exercise with or without a behavioral approach compared with a physical activity prescription in chronic whiplash disorder. J Rehabil Med. 2016;48(1):56-64. ↩ Back to text
22. Michaleff ZA, Maher CG, Lin CW, Rebbeck T, Jull G, Latimer J, et al. Comprehensive physiotherapy exercise program or advice for chronic whiplash (PROMISE): a pragmatic randomized controlled trial. Lancet. 2014;384(9938):133-41. ↩ Back to text
23. Stewart MJ, Maher CG, Refshauge KM, Herbert RD, Bogduk N, Nicholas M. Randomized controlled trial of exercise for chronic whiplash-associated disorders. Pain. 2007;128(1-2):59-68. ↩ Back to text
24. South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. Deep neck flexion in the supine position. ↩ Back to text
25. Jull G, Falla D, Treleaven J, Hodges P, Vicenzino B. Retraining cervical joint position sense: the effect of two exercise regimens. J Orthop Res. 2007;25(3):404-12. ↩ Back to text
26. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS). Rotator Cuff and Shoulder Conditioning Program. OrthoInfo. ↩ Back to text
27. North Bristol NHS Trust. eRehab Therapy: Vestibular. ↩ Back to text
28. Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust. Strength and Balance Exercise Program. ↩ Back to text
29. Kamper SJ, Rebbeck TJ, Maher CG, McAuley JH, Sterling M. Course and prognostic factors of whiplash: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Pain. 2008;138(3):617-629. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd citations
30. Ritchie C, Sterling M. Recovery Pathways and Prognosis After Whiplash Injury. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2016;46(10):851-861. ↩ Back to text
31. Rosenfeld M, Gunnarsson R, Borenstein P. Early intervention in whiplash-associated disorders: a comparison of two treatment protocols. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2000;25(14):1782-7. ↩ Back to text: 1st, 2nd citations
32. Côté P, Cassidy JD, Carroll L, Frank JW, Bombardier C. A systematic review of the prognosis of acute whiplash and a new conceptual framework to synthesize the literature. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2001;26(19):E445-58. ↩ Back to text
33. Dehner C, Hartwig E, Strobel P, Scheich M, Schneider F, Elbel M, et al. Comparison of the relative benefits of 2 versus 10 days of soft-collar cervical immobilization after acute whiplash injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2006;87(11):1423-7. ↩ Back to text
34. Bunketorp L, Lindh M, Carlsson J, Stener-Victorin E. The effectiveness of a supervised physical training model tailored to the individual needs of patients with whiplash-associated disorders—a randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil. 2006;20(3):201-17. ↩ Back to text

Our physical therapists defined the research strategy, plan, and clinical content of this article. An AI tool assisted with the literature review and text editing to ensure consistency in content and writing style.